VinnitoElito's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Good and the Bad]

I remember when this and the video came out on youtube on your channel. I feel your pain still. It can take a long time to recover sometimes.

MetalRenard responds:

Yeah, thanks Vinnito.
I wanted to make this song available for others to download and use. It just felt like the right thing to do.

[Retrograde Planet]

The first half is enjoyable in my opinion, and I'm not sure what the fuss is about.
I can indeed complain its lengthy, and it is, a repetitive beat, but it is an intro meant to be as you said, an atmospheric composition, used as an opening.
I believe cutting the intro in half would be silly, 10 seconds is a-lot better, since it takes about that long for it to loop its sound.
On the latter half... I'm amazed you created something so wonderful! It could be a part of its own chiptune dedicated to similar compositions if you went to expand upon it in a future submission. It indeed attracted much attention and popularity, I enjoy it too.
While writing this review the whole song looped over 5 times. Cause I absorbed quite a bit each time I went and typed a sentence.

[Cracklebin]

Well... it serves its purpose well... painful on the ears... and yet... somehow in the back of my mind I see art with this... that it maintains itself on a quality level without becoming ear grating junk is impressive as some people mistakenly create mindless noise rather than art when attempting things like this. Kudos for you for making art.

[Brace For Impact]

This is pretty damn impressive! That you have story behind this, as well as in this, is even more amazing! Incredible!

[Club Desire ~P~]

This is actually really good. It's somewhat different than other things of yours I listen to, but I really enjoyed this. Great job!

[Smells Like Rain]

This music is one of the most complicated, creative, and enjoyable delights you've produced yet!

[The Keepers Secret Garden]

One of your best!

[When Rumors Prove True]

This is pretty good! You have made better mind you, and this doesn't sound as good as music from some old school RPGs I've played. But its still fine.

[A Dance with Delusions]

Am loving this!

[Funky Derp]

I like this a lot. It sounds fun and exciting. That is what I enjoy with this kind of music. It makes a decent loop too.